Shelter Island town Population

2010–2026

3,367

2026 projection

4% since 2020 (increase)

05001K1.5K2K2.5K3K3.5K201020122014201620182020202220242026

Source: U.S. Census Bureau decennial counts and annual estimates, including 2010–2020 intercensal estimates. 2026 is a projection. Values between recorded years are interpolated.

Use the left and right arrow keys to inspect population observations.

Population by year

Population estimates for Shelter Island town. Annual change is shown as a percentage. Growth is the total change since the preceding observation.
20263,367+160.48%
20253,351+160.48%
20243,335+371.12%
20233,298+250.76%
20223,273+100.31%
20213,263+270.83%
20203,236+82234.05%
20192,414-30.12%
20182,417+70.29%
20172,41000.00%

Showing 10 of 17 years.

Growth since 2020, compared

Shelter Island town is growing faster than Suffolk County, New York, and the U.S.

  • Shelter Island town+3.6%
  • United States+3.1%
  • Suffolk County+1.6%
  • New York−0.6%

Change from July 1, 2020 to July 1, 2025 population estimates—not annualized growth or site projections.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau. U.S. totals are summed from the 50 states and D.C.; unavailable comparisons are omitted.

Shelter Island town Demographics

50median age

Median age

Female42.7 yrs
Male55.4 yrs

Adults

2,775
1,211 seniors (65+) · 44% of adults1,564 other adults

Sex

Female 56.4% · 1,891Male 43.6% · 1,464

U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 ACS 5-year estimates · Table S0101

Race and ethnicity

Tap a square or a group below to highlight it.

Each square is about 1% of residents (roughly 34 people).

Hispanic or Latino residents can be of any race. All other groups exclude Hispanic residents.

U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 ACS 5-year estimates · Table B03002

Shelter Island town Income

$133,967median household income

Median household income

$133,967

Half of households earn more, half earn less

Median earnings

$98,518

Typical yearly pay for a worker 25 or older.

Poverty rate

6%

About 1 in 17 residents

U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 ACS 5-year estimates · Tables S1901, S1501, S1701

Shelter Island town Marital Status

53% of residents age 15 and older are married.

MarriedNever married
Overall
Male
Female
Marital status of residents age 15 and older
StatusOverallMaleFemale
Married53%60%47%
Never married28%29%27%
Divorced11%11%12%
Widowed8%0%15%
Separated<1%<1%0%

U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 ACS 5-year estimates · Table S1201